Real Estate ArticlesReal Estate FAQs March 18, 2025

Negotiating Your Offer for The One

Making an offer on a home is a big step, but it’s just the beginning of the process. Negotiating Your Offer for The One is where you and the seller work to agree on a price and terms that work for both of you. A well-planned negotiation strategy can save you money, get you better terms, and ensure you feel confident in your home purchase. Whether you’re a buyer trying to get the best deal or a seller looking to maximize your profit, understanding how to negotiate is key.

1. Start with a Strong, but Fair Offer

Your initial offer sets the tone for negotiations. If you go too low, the seller might reject it outright or not take you seriously. If you offer too much, you could end up overpaying. Your real estate agent will help you research comparable sales (known as “comps”) to determine a competitive offer price.

A strong offer includes more than just price—it also shows you’re a serious buyer. Make sure to include:

  • A pre-approval or pre-qualification letter from your lender to prove you’re financially ready.
  • A reasonable earnest money deposit to show your commitment.
  • A clean, straightforward offer that doesn’t include too many demands upfront.

2. Be Prepared for a Counteroffer

Most sellers won’t accept the first offer right away. Instead, they may counter with a higher price or request different terms. At this stage, you have three choices:
✅ Accept the seller’s counteroffer and move forward.
✅ Counter their counteroffer with your own adjustments.
✅ Walk away if the deal no longer makes sense for you.

Your real estate agent will guide you through the counteroffer process of negotiating your offer for The One and help you decide how to respond strategically.

3. Negotiate More Than Just Price

While the purchase price is a big factor, there are other parts of the offer that can be negotiated to benefit you. If the seller is firm on price, you might be able to negotiate on:

  • Closing costs – Ask the seller to cover part of your closing expenses.
  • Repairs – After the home inspection, negotiate for repairs or a credit to cover the costs.
  • Closing date – Some sellers need more time to move, while others want to close quickly. Flexibility can work in your favor.
  • Personal property – Want that stainless steel fridge or the washer and dryer? Ask for it in the deal!

4. Understand the Market Conditions

The way you negotiate depends on whether it’s a buyer’s market or a seller’s market:

  • Buyer’s Market – When there are more homes for sale than buyers, you have more power to negotiate for a lower price and better terms.
  • Seller’s Market – When there are more buyers than available homes, you may have to offer at or above asking price and limit your negotiation requests.

Knowing the market can help you set the right expectations and approach the negotiation with a winning strategy.

5. Use Contingencies to Protect Yourself

Contingencies are conditions that must be met before the sale is finalized. While too many contingencies can make your offer less appealing, some are essential:

  • Inspection Contingency – Allows you to back out if the home has major issues.
  • Financing Contingency – Protects you if your mortgage doesn’t get final approval.
  • Appraisal Contingency – Ensures you don’t overpay for a home that appraises for less than the offer price.

The key is to balance protecting yourself with making your offer attractive to the seller.

6. Stay Calm and Be Ready to Walk Away

Buying a home is an emotional process, but it’s important to stay level-headed. If negotiations aren’t going in your favor and you feel pressured into an offer that doesn’t feel right, be prepared to walk away. There are always other homes, and a deal should never feel forced.

Negotiation is a key part of buying and selling a home. Buyers should focus on making a competitive offer while looking for ways to improve the terms to their advantage. Sellers should stay open to offers while knowing when to stand firm.

Having an experienced real estate agent by your side makes all the difference in navigating negotiations successfully. Ready to make an offer? Let’s negotiate a deal that works for you! 🏡💰

Now that you know all about the fifth step in the home buying process, let’s move on to #6! To see the whole 10 step process check out our blog article: The 10 Steps to Buying a Home.


If you enjoyed Negotiating Your Offer for The One, make sure to check out ERA Liberty’s other blog articles. We blog about all things real estate, local eats, and happenings in and around our community.

For all your home buying or selling needs, ERA Liberty Realty is always there for you! We are here to help you no matter where you are, we have agents licensed in West Virginia, Virginia, Maryland, or Washington DC! Reach out today to get your real estate journey started!